Growing Up Graphically
Posted by Fliss | Posted in Book Reviews | Posted on 15-10-2010
0
I used to read quite a few graphic novels during my teens; not as much as some of the people I went to school with, who were aficionado’s, of a sort, and often seemed to be employing some kind of private language when they were talking to each other, but, then, they were mainly teenage boys, so I could say that about almost anything they were talking about. In any case, I was too busy indulging my own secret literary peccadilloes at the time to really explore the genre seriously, and, eventually, I stopped reading them all together – at least, until this year. As it is, I have slowly been reintroducing the graphic genre to my literary palette, and I have actually really enjoyed the process.
The first graphic novel I read this year was purchased on something of a whim with some money I had received for my birthday, so, choosing from the two books my local indie book shop had in stock, I walked home with Persepolis by Marjane Satrapi, which was a book I had been meaning to read for ages, but which I was extremely nervous about choosing as my first graphic novel to read after so many years. My nervousness was mainly due to the fact that I had seen the film, and really liked it, and I thought the book would not live up to my expectations, raised even higher by the rave reviews the book had recieved.
As it was, as powerful, funny and moving as I found the film, I thought the book was ten times better. For anyone who doesn’t know anything about the book (after all the press it has received, I am not certain such people exist), Persepolis is Marjane Satrapi’s memoir of her life in Iran, from before the beginning of the revolution, when she was a small child, to the point of her final departure from the country as a young woman, taking in her time as a voluntary exile in Switzerland during her adolescence, and covering topics from the political oppression in Iran to first love and family relations.
The thing that makes the book so powerful for me, though, is that Satrapi switches so effortlessly from the seeming normality of her childhood to the horrific consequences of war with such ease that it always comes as a shock to turn the page and see something heartbreaking, moments after reading about a conversation over something quite domestic with one member of her family or another. It is the recognisability of the family situations, then, coupled with the totally alien abnormality of terrible violence (at least in terms of my own experience) and personal loss that so emotionally moved me.
Added to this, while the film made excellent use of a narrator, the fact that you are reading the book in silence makes the experience even more intense. Even more importantly, as a reader, rather than a viewer, you can control exactly how much time you devote to each frame of the book, looking for fine details and really being drawn into Satrapi’s world, all of which made me really glad that I ignored my slight wobble over whether to read the book or not and made me really glad I did.
Now, from the sublime to the ridiculous, as they say, but in a good way in this instance, as I next found myself reading the first volume of Bryan Lee O’Malley’s Scott Pilgrim series (which has just been made into a film, in case you didn’t know), Scott Pilgrim’s Precious Little Life, detailing the everyday life of 23-year-old professional layabout Scott Pilgrim. Scott is pretty much the definition of a slacker, having no job, spongeing of his gay roommate Wallace, with whom he shares a bed, spending his time playing computer games and rehearsing with his band.
His trouble really starts when he begins dating a school girl, 17 year old Knives Chau, while simultaneously starting to have dreams about a roller-skating delivery girl, Ramona Flowers, and starts receiving mysterious emails from someone who apparently wants to fight. It turns out that Ramona is actually using a short-cut that runs right through Scott’s brain (surreal, no?) but, before Scott can actually start dating Ramona properly, he must defeat her evil exes, and, as it turns out, the mysterious emails he has been deleting without reading are actually quite important.
There are more than a few surreal moments in Scott Pilgrim’s Precious Little Life, which I like, so, you know, I’m fine with that, but what really made the book a success for me, and made me determined to get my hands on the rest of the series, was the humour of the book, and I did actually laugh out loud at a couple of points. Added to this, the cast of characters are wacky yet genuinely charming (and I love Wallace), and O’Malley exploits the graphic novel genre to tell Scott’s story in the most energetic and interesting way possible.
The third book I read was, for me, not quite as good as either of the other two, in part because Ghost World by Daniel Clowes seems to sit uneasily in the middle ground between the surreal funniness of Scott Pilgrim and the serious coming of age elements of Persepolis. I also found that the fact that the book had been a serialisation originally really stopped me from getting into the book.
It was still an interesting book to read, and the relationship between Enid and Rebecca, the two central protagonists, was interesting to read about. The trouble is, there isn’t really that much of a plot as the book is more of an exploration of the nature of adolescence and friendship, and, essentially, the inevitability of growing up and, sometimes, apart. The trouble is, my adolescence was completely different from Enid and Rebecca’s so I felt as if Clowes was documenting some alien species and, really, I just didn’t much like any of the characters, and, when you get right down to it, I think that if you don’t really care what happens to anyone in a book then you are never going to particularly enjoy, but I would still say that it is worth reading if you have an interest in graphic novels, just as a point of comparison. Still, while I will definitely be reading more work by both Satrapi and O’Malley, I really don’t think Clowes’s work is for me.











